Ron Welch
Muskingum County Prosecutor
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Friday, November 20, 2026
False Domestic Violence Report Results in 9 Month Prison Sentence for Roseville Woman
(ZANESVILLE, OH)
Hope Smith, 25, appeared in the Muskingum Court of Common Pleas to learn her fate after admitting guilt to all the charges in her indictment. Those charges included: Abduction, a felony of the third degree, Misuse of 911 System, a misdemeanor of the fourth degree, and Falsification, a misdemeanor of the first degree.
The charges stem from Smith lying to the police in order to have a domestic partner arrested on false claims of domestic violence.
Smith appeared before Judge Kelly Cottrill who imposed a 9-month prison sentence.
FACTS OF THE CASE:
On July 12, 2026, officers were dispatched to a residence in reference to a domestic violence call. Upon arriving, Hope Smith reported to officers that a man attacked her following an argument.
Smith reported that the man had been drinking. She claimed that she attempted to take a bottle of alcohol from him and upon doing so he dropped the bottle, causing it to break.
Smith lied and told the police that the man then grabbed her from behind, wrapping his arms around her neck and his legs around her abdomen. She told the officers that he squeezed her throat causing her to be unable to breathe or talk. Officers then arrested the man, based on Smith’s story. Smith’s abduction charge originated from the fact that her lies caused the police to arrest the man she falsely accused.
Abduction is an offense that involves restraining someone of their liberty. In Ohio, every crime includes situations where the offense is committed by “complicity.” In this case, Smith was complicit to abduction because she caused an innocent person – the police - to commit acts that completed her crime.
When Detective Bryan Ruff interviewed the innocent man, he professed his innocence and claimed that Smith had made the entire scenario up.
Later, at the man’s initial court hearing Hope Smith came forth and told the truth, informing Detective Ruff that she made untrue statements and lied on the 911 call as well as on her domestic violence report.
Assistant Prosecuting Attorney Warren Edwards represented the State.
“Making a false allegation of criminal conduct is one of the most despicable crimes an individual can commit, not only because of the impact it could have on the wrongly accused, but also because it undermines real victims when they come forward,” according to APA Edwards.
“Fortunately, here in Muskingum County, we are very skilled at discerning the truth from lies, and will not allow our criminal justice system to be manipulated to serve a personal grudge."
Manipulating public servants, telling lies, and wasting the resources of first responders is a serious crime, but not as serious as having another person wrongly put in jail. Domestic violence is also a serious crime, and the overwhelming majority of domestic violence related cases involve real victims, and real harm.
If you have experienced domestic violence, please report that abuse to law enforcement. Victim advocates are also available through Transitions, at 740-454-3213.
###
Follow the Muskingum County Prosecutor’s Office on Facebook for the most current and complete information.